Read the article at the link below and answer the following questions. Your response should be at least 5-7 sentences. Make sure to include evidence from the text:
1. What argument is presented in the article?
2. What is a possible alternative argument? What evidence would be needed to support the alternative argument?
http://learning.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/04/29/should-certain-animals-have-some-of-the-same-legal-rights-as-people/?_php=true&_type=blogs&module=BlogPost-ReadMore&version=Blog%20Main&action=Click&contentCollection=U.S.&pgtype=Blogs®ion=Body&_r=0#more-145106
the argument that steven wise have is that animals should have person rights. he said that certain animals should be treated like humans. i agree with that. my alternative for that is it should add more laws to protect animals.
ReplyDeleteThey Should Have Animal Rights.They Should Be Free Like Humans.
ReplyDeleteAlso Because Some Animals Has Been Abused And Hurt And Killed By Some Humans.Some Die From Hunger,Abuse,etc.
That animals need to be treated like HUMANS.HUMANS need to be fair to animals. What if they got treated like that.How do you think animals feel!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! They are hurt on the inside.Think about it.
ReplyDelete1. The argument that is presented in this article is that animals are people too and they don't need to be treated like they are experiments or something. I agree with Dr. Wise because they dont feel comfortable being used as experiment and tested with medicine.
ReplyDelete2. The argument is that Dr. Wise wanted people to stop killing and experimenting animals that are bearly harmless i guess they don't care because they keep doing it to them.ANd my evidence is that they show us little short of they experiment on them in TUBES and all you could hear was their weaping voices cherp for help its very sad.
that there fighting for animals laws like humans!!!!!!!!***** Also their rights mean something to people so thats why hes fighting
ReplyDeleteThe argument is about how certain species of animals should have human rights. One possible argument is they can stop using animals as lab rats. Lots of scientists use animals to test new products.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI think that all animals should have rights because animals are not treated unfairly. I say this because I have 5 different dogs in 5 different places so I will treat all animals equally
Deletethe argument he is trying to make is that animals should have better rights then they have now.they should not have to be treated like lab rats.
ReplyDeletewe should give animals rights but the same rights we have no matter what god still put animals on earth he put them on earth for a reason and i know not to be killed and not to be mean to
ReplyDeletethe article that is presented is how animals should have human rights.
ReplyDeletethe alternative argument is how animals are being abused or hurt by humans.
the evidence i would need is how some animals are treated and what rights do the people want to give the animals.
I think this man is doing a great thing to help the animals.But also i think this man is doing the wrong thing because you cant make animals have the same rights as people but u can make animals have better rights
ReplyDeleteThe argument That Is presented Is How They Should Let Monkeys Do What Humans. Also like Talk Like Us Human . They Want To Be Like Us .So The Man Is Going To Try And Certain Monekeys Get Like Us Besides Being In Cages In Haveing To Talk Off A Computer.
ReplyDeleteI think that they are very wrong for what they did to those animals because we all know that monkeys act as if they have human brains so those animal murders should think about what they did because what if it happened to them, monkeys have feelings too, they are just like us so I really don't see the point of them killing those monkeys.
ReplyDeletethis argument is about the monkeys having human rights
ReplyDeleteHumans don't give animals enough respect that they deserve. And the alternative argument is that animals already get the respect they deserve.
ReplyDeleteThe argument is about how the man want monkeys to have there rights.he wants to help them .i think they should have there on rights or they should have there on rights as monkey
ReplyDeleteThe argument in "Animals are Persons Too" was that certain species of animals should have rights and be protected by law. Steven Wise is stating that If they are protected by law or they improved laws then no animals would be used as an experiment or in other terms they will not be harmed. I agree with this statement but it would be crazy to give them the same rights as humans just improve the laws!
ReplyDeleteHe is trying to let the animals get their freedom like how we got freedom some animals got hurt and etc so that is why he is fighting for the animals right.And they should have more laws for them
ReplyDeletethe argument is about how certain species of animals should have human rights one possible argument is they can stop using animals as lab rats lots of scientist use animals to test new products. also instead of trying to teat them like humans they need to give them more learning products so they can be more intellegent.
ReplyDeleteThe argument in the article is certain animals should have legal rights. The evidence is the guy trying to give animals rights say they should have a high intelligents like chimps . An alternative is to have them educated better
ReplyDelete1.He wanted people to stop killing the animals because he card for them
ReplyDelete2. One possible argument is that scientist need to stop using animals for lab experiments